What happened to the Dasa thread?

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
In fact, he merely sought to bring terrible acts of persecution to the
forums attention, perpetrated by Muslims on a christian minority, it happens.

In fact, he sought to extrapolate from some criminal cases and apply it to all Muslims. Didn't you read the OP on his thread? He went much further than just bringing "terrible acts" to the forums attention. It's an odd thing for you to claim. If you didn't actually read the OP [because if you did, you are misrepresenting it] are you sure you are in a position to comment on its content?

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Unbelievable, Christians must suffer all manner of insults against their God

This is interesting. So you own God? When I insult your God you suffer? If I insult your God, does every Christian suffer or only those in your denomination? Must one be a believer in order to suffer as a result of your God being insulted?

Originally posted by Proper Knob
Comparing a fictional God to a despot can hardly be called 'hate speech'. If i made a claim that 'Zeus or Isiris was akin to Hilter' would you term that hate speech? I don't think so.

The claim that Dasa made which i thought broke the ToS, was that [b]ALL Muslims were child rapists and paedophiles.[/b]

When sunhouse compared me to Hitler, did you think that broke the ToS?

Originally posted by RJHinds
When sunhouse compared me to Hitler, did you think that broke the ToS?

I have no idea, i haven't read it.

Originally posted by Proper Knob
I have no idea, i haven't read it.

Well, I guess it is too late now. It appears to be gone.

Originally posted by RJHinds
Well, I guess it is too late now. It appears to be gone.

Well next time if there is something you feel breaks the ToS, just alert a moderator. I do find it slightly ironic that you of all people should be quibbling about breaking the ToS.

Originally posted by RJHinds
When sunhouse compared me to Hitler, did you think that broke the ToS?

Exactly how did I compare you to Hitler? If I did, I apologize. Heated discussion.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Did some namby pamby secular liberal like Finnegan alert it because it did not sit right
with his Islamophile sensibilities? What happened to free speech? We get enough hate
speech from the anti-christians here, your God is like Hitler etc etc, yet the posts
remain, so why remove Dasas post?

I agree with filtering on the use of the last name of der Führer and deleting all posts* that contain both it and "God."

*Edit: to Spirituality

Will that level the playing field enough for you?

Originally posted by Agerg
Crap comparison...

"G"od hasn't been demonstrated real
When we call your "G"od a monster we are talking about one specific entity for which a holy book associated with it implies this being is a genicidal thick as pig-s*** psycho

Muslims have been demonstrated real
Dasa is denegrating an entire collection of people based on the actions of a minorty of those people

whether you consider God as real or otherwise is not the point, is it, free speech is
being stifled. Its hypocritical of you and all those who objected to dasas post to allow
certain forms of hate speech and report those which you support. Its an excellent
comparison.

Originally posted by JS357
I agree with filtering on the use of the last name of der Führer and deleting all posts* that contain both it and "God."

*Edit: to Spirituality

Will that level the playing field enough for you?

either we allow freedom of speech, in any form, or we report all of it. I am thoroughly
bemused at those who profess to be liberally minded that their sensitivities should be
so offended by dasas opening post when day in day out Christians are subject to
similar offensive remarks but do not object. Your God is a mass murderer, a psychotic
serial killer, the same as Hitler etc etc etc , will you now please explain why this is in
any shape of form dissimilar to the type of hate speech which dasa posts? I cannot see
it myself, perhaps you have a better grasp of the subtleties.

Originally posted by FMF
In fact, he sought to extrapolate from some criminal cases and apply it to all Muslims. Didn't you read the OP on his thread? He went much further than just bringing "terrible acts" to the forums attention. It's an odd thing for you to claim. If you didn't actually read the OP [because if you did, you are misrepresenting it] are you sure you are in a position to comment on its content?

Were those acts perpetrated by Muslims on a Christian minority, if the answer is yes,
then the question is, how does this reflect on Islam, Islamic society and all professing
Muslims, its a valid topic, but to dismiss it on the basis of some kind of moral
sensibilities is an affront to intelligence and free speech. So you think its odd, so what?
Its not about me and don't even try your no obligatory trade mark, the ad hominem, I
repeat, its not about me, its about free speech and my perceived hypocrisy of those
who alerted that post.

Originally posted by FMF
Dasa advocated the genocide of all Muslim men at the end of last year. He has repeatedly refused to take back a single word of it and says he stands by what he said.

irrelevent.

Originally posted by stellspalfie
tosh. god is one person and claims against him are backed up with evidence from the bible. dasa uses examples in which he doesnt give evidence. he also uses several individual examples to condemn millions of people. not exactly the same is it.


did you skip breakfast today? you dont seem on the ball.

If God allowed even Satan himself to enter in among the angelic hordes and give an
account of his activities, i think that says it all about Gods magnanimity and mankind's
small-mindedness. It was construed that the post was racist, Islam is not a race, it
could not therefore have been racist. I want to know, from those people who alerted it,
on what basis were they offended.

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
. I am thoroughly
bemused at those who profess to be liberally minded that their sensitivities should be
so offended by dasas opening post when day in day out Christians are subject to
similar offensive remarks but do not object. Your God is a mass murderer, a psychotic
serial killer, the same as Hitler etc etc etc , will you now please exp ...[text shortened]... which dasa posts? I cannot see
it myself, perhaps you have a better grasp of the subtleties.

So I guess you didn't like my idea.

I can't put myself in the brain of the mods who banned removed Dasa's post, as to how it differs from a H****r/God post and my guess is no better than anybody's.

I would favor a system where we could individually "opt into" or "opt out of" the RHP censorship protocols, akin to turning Google's safe search on or off.

Originally posted by JS357
So I guess you didn't like my idea.

I can't put myself in the brain of the mods who banned removed Dasa's post, as to how it differs from a H****r/God post and my guess is no better than anybody's.

I would favor a system where we could individually "opt into" or "opt out of" the RHP censorship protocols, akin to turning Google's safe search on or off.

yes i think your ideas are good i just needed another's perspective as i cannot see
clearly myself, by that i mean, i cannot see the distinction between dasas and some of
the other posts, this is further compounded by the excuses that have been proffered by
those who objected to his post, it really is a quandary to be honest.