Go back
Are people basically good?

Are people basically good?

Spirituality


Originally posted by @whodey
Well?
As the result of working within the British justice system (now retired) I have frequently come across the darker side of human nature and behaviour. There are some for whom societal constraints seem to apply much more weakly than others. Nonetheless I have generally believed in "nurture over nature" and that "no-one is born evil" although I recognise there have been one or two cases where a person's behaviour defeats current psychological understanding and thus seems to have been simply "wired wrong".

I think in any given moment it is possible to choose to do something good without be defined by the actions thoughts and fears of the past and thus that some spiritual practices have encompassed this "wisdom" before they passed into mainstream psychotherapy.

1 edit


-Removed-
What is Jesus implying in your estimation if that is a metaphor? If He is using language that
is metaphoric that spells out in your opinion eternal torture, what is He implying by doing
that? How do you read His Words and all of those text throughout the Bible?


-Removed-
Im not part of the church Christian community, and maybe that makes a difference. Church Christians often feel obligated to support their church doctrine so that these kinds of questions you ask make them uncomfortable.


1 edit

-Removed-
It seems troubling for them even as a metaphor ... sometimes no response is louder than a response.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by @rajk999
How is that relevant to the opening posr
Because if you are not righteous before God as God requires you are not righteous enough.


-Removed-
I'm not missing the point, I asked you what you think Jesus meant by using the
"METAPHOR" He did. Answer that, I think its literal I've announced that enough I wouldn't
think you'd need to ask. What I have not seen is what do YOU think the point was that
Jesus was making using the "METAPHOR" the clearly sounds as if eternal punishment
is in play?


Originally posted by @kellyjay
Because if you are not righteous before God as God requires you are not righteous enough.
Jesus described in very great detail who it is that are righteous enough to enter the Kingdom of God. It is a very clear description of people doing good works. Maybe you have not come across it. Let me know and I will post the references.

Even in the stories of the Rich man and Lazarus, the rich man lived a selfish life and went to hell in torment and the poor man was taken to heaven. In the Good Samaritan story the priest and the Levite both people of faith, failed to do good works and they would not be in the Kingdom of God.

Its not rocket science. The qualification to enter the Kingdom of God is good works and righteousness. God is pleased with that.

You do not believe in that. You instead make these vague pronouncements of having the Spirit of Christ which is nonsensical mambo jumbo. Your doctrine misses the mark by a mile and does not clearly spell out for people what is required of them.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by @rajk999
Jesus described in very great detail who it is that are righteous enough to enter the Kingdom of God. It is a very clear description of people doing good works. Maybe you have not come across it. Let me know and I will post the references.

Even in the stories of the Rich man and Lazarus, the rich man lived a selfish life and went to hell in torment and t ...[text shortened]... ne misses the mark by a mile and does not clearly spell out for people what is required of them.
Never denied that those entering will do good works, but does it say anywhere specifically
do good works so you are good enough to enter into God's kingdom? I can point to where it
says the righteous are to do good works, and where it says it isn't by works we are saved.


Originally posted by @kellyjay
Never denied that those entering will do good works, but does it say anywhere specifically
do good works so you are good enough to enter into God's kingdom? I can point to where it
says the righteous are to do good works, and where it says it isn't by works we are saved.
In Matt 25 it was because the sheep did good works they were good enough to enter the Kingdom of God.
It was because the goats did not do good works they were barred from entry.

Saved is not the same as eternal life.

Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
To that guy he was speaking to it was very literal.


Originally posted by @kellyjay
Never denied that those entering will do good works, but does it say anywhere specifically
do good works so you are good enough to enter into God's kingdom? I can point to where it
says the righteous are to do good works, and where it says it isn't by works we are saved.
Where does it say that the righteous are to do good works?
What does that mean.

Is it some someone is proclaimed righteous and then they are supposed to do good works? Suppose they do not do good works what then.

That makes no sense.


Originally posted by @rajk999
In Matt 25 it was because the sheep did good works they were good enough to enter the Kingdom of God.
It was because the goats did not do good works they were barred from entry.

Saved is not the same as eternal life.
Before you pat yourself on the back, what made a sheep, a sheep, and a goat, a goat?
They where sorted long before the works were come into play.

Matthew 3:12
His winnowing fork is in his hand, and he will clear his threshing floor and gather his wheat into the barn, but the chaff he will burn with unquenchable fire.”


Originally posted by @kellyjay
Before you pat yourself on the back, what made a sheep, a sheep, and a goat, a goat?
They where sorted long before the works were come into play.

Matthew 3:12
His winnowing fork is in his hand, and he will clear his threshing floor and gather his wheat into the barn, but the chaff he will burn with unquenchable fire.”
Nonsense. No such thing is in the bible. i will leave you to wallow in your false garbage church doctrine.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.