Go back
Creation vs. Evolution

Creation vs. Evolution

Spirituality

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Treytrumpet1
You see, the very fact that a car is here and that the body of the car is placed as such for an engine to be assembed and placed inside, and a transmission and axil and wheels and tires working together shows DESIGN. I know that since cars are designed, there must be a designer, which is the car manufacturer.
Actually the only reason why you believe that a car is evidence for car manufacturers is because you know about the existence of car manufacturers. You do not have any other valid reason for believing the car to be designed.
When the wind blows the sea it creates waves. If you looked at one wave and the beauty of its form and the way in which it travels across the surface of the sea etc etc you would conclude that it was designed would you not? So does God design every wave? Are all patterns evidence for design? What rule are you using to make such conclusions? Surely the only real argument you have is "I am too stupid to see how it could have come about via any process other than design".

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by twhitehead
Actually the only reason why you believe that a car is evidence for car manufacturers is because you know about the existence of car manufacturers. You do not have any other valid reason for believing the car to be designed.
When the wind blows the sea it creates waves. If you looked at one wave and the beauty of its form and the way in which it travels ...[text shortened]... ve is "I am too stupid to see how it could have come about via any process other than design".
Indeed.
A belief in God ironically often indicates a remarkable lack of imagination.

If He is such a great designer can someone please explain what good a random cell in a fruit fly turning cancerous does the world?

Or perhaps why over 25% of human embryos are naturally miscarried in the first 6 weeks?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Squelchbelch
Indeed.
A belief in God ironically often indicates a remarkable lack of imagination.

If He is such a great designer can someone please explain what good a random cell in a fruit fly turning cancerous does the world?

Or perhaps why over 25% of human embryos are naturally miscarried in the first 6 weeks?
Thats and easy one! All bad things in the world are a result of sin. 🙂

2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Treytrumpet1
I submit to you that we can know that God exists. Some assert that there is not enough evidence for proof that such is in existence; however this response will attempt to submit that very evidence that is supposedly lacking. It may be that those who would say that there is no proof that God exists, care not to examine or even look for such evidence. s absolutely overwhelming evidence for an intelligent Designer: that Designer is God.
That's the most stupid argument I ever seen. You don't understand a thing about science. "Intelligent Design".... Go to a normal school learn basic stuff and refrain from telling unjustified non-sense.
You're argument is: "Look, is everything so beautiful and complex, it must have been made by a super-intelligent being."
If you don't comprehend the processes behind, that's a completely different thing.

Look at fractals. Are they intelligently designed? No! They are ultra-simple to explain mathematically, yet they are INFINITELY complex and beautiful. Did God create them too?
And how about deterministic chaos? (of course you don't know what this is), it's infinitely complex, unexpected behavior, just like nature, and SO easy to explain... just a couple of differential equations and a couple of parameters are necessary.
If you need a God , that's one thing. If nature needs a god to explain itself, let me tell you: IT DOESN'T.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by KellyJay
My judgment comes from me? You again have a point?
Kelly
...based on your faith?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Treytrumpet1
I submit to you that we can know that God exists. Some assert that there is not enough evidence for proof that such is in existence; however this response will attempt to submit that very evidence that is supposedly lacking. It may be that those who would say that there is no proof that God exists, care not to examine or even look for such evidence. ...[text shortened]... s absolutely overwhelming evidence for an intelligent Designer: that Designer is God.
Do you understand what evolution means? And what the result of evolution would be, in all these things you mention (except cars)?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by twhitehead
Thats and easy one! All bad things in the world are a result of sin. 🙂
The fruit fly sinned so it got cancer?
😕

Vote Up
Vote Down

Just remembered an awfully stupid question...
If evolution did not happen at all and all men descend from Adam and Eve, from where did black and asian people descend?

Vote Up
Vote Down

I'm not certain how healthy this conversation is. People spend too much time attacking one another. I am fairly sure that evolution is correct based upon mounds of scientific data which back it up. I am also comfortable with the idea that there is no intelligent design and no God.

This does not mean, however, that I need to engage in an attack upon anyone regarding the issue. What everyone needs to do is analyze why they believe what they do - even me. My past experiences, education, etc. have led me to my belief system, and all people - religious or otherwise - should determine what prejudices we have coddled while forming our belief systems.

After all, we could all be wrong...

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ou Lei
I'm not certain how healthy this conversation is. People spend too much time attacking one another. I am fairly sure that evolution is correct based upon mounds of scientific data which back it up. I am also comfortable with the idea that there is no intelligent design and no God.

This does not mean, however, that I need to engage in an attack upon anyon ...[text shortened]... udices we have coddled while forming our belief systems.

After all, we could all be wrong...
if only everyone was you, we'd all be smart enough to see our faith is wrong.... *sigh*

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by telerion
[b]So you have an issue with inference through time, especially when the event cannot be reproduced currently.

Would you be more comfortable with the statement: "All empirical evidence strongly suggests that the earth is approximately 3.2 billion years old?"
Actually, it's closer to 4.4 billion years old.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by serigado
And about dinosaurs and men coexisting?[/b]
Whoaaaa Nelly! Dinosaurs and men co-existing? Who's arguing THAT dead-bang loser? Are the "men" Cro-Magnon? Neanderthal? Homo sapiens ???!!!

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by twhitehead
Thats and easy one! All bad things in the world are a result of sin. 🙂
I do not know if you are attempting to be funny or simply answering
the question, but yes. Sin brought death and the planet was cursed
due to it. Without this place would be quite different.
Kelly

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Squelchbelch
The fruit fly sinned so it got cancer?
😕
No, Adam sinned so God cursed the earth and all living things on it. I wonder if aliens are cancer free or if Gods curse covered the entire universe.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by snowinscotland
...based on your faith?
We all base what we think is right and wrong based on all that is us,
and yes faith is part of you as it is me. I believe that the Bible is the
Word of God, others have other things they also rely on, does that
change anything, it is part of who we are. I do not understand your
continued question, if you do not know how to figure out right and
wrong for yourself, you should be careful some one else will tell you.
Kelly